Jump to:
- Presidential
Politics
and the 2009 election
- Children's
issues--why do we go to Honduras?
- The
2009 Earthquake
- Anti-sweat
shop actions
- 2009 World Cup
- Further
reading
back to top
The 2009 military coup and
the US State Depoartment Travel Alert to Honduras:
On November 6, 2009
the US State Department issued a Travel
Alert for Honduras:
"The Department of State alerts U.S. citizens to the
current uncertain political and security situation in Honduras, and
recommends that American citizens exercise caution when traveling to
Honduras, while deferring all non-essential travel to the capital city
of Tegucigalpa until further notice. This Travel Alert expires on
December 20, 2009."
The alert is in response to demonstrations following the
ousting of elected President Manuel Zelaya and his replacement by
former head of Congress, Roberto Micheletti. Although most of the
demonstrations have been in the capital city, Tegucigalpa, the warning
expresses concern that they might spread as the data of the electon
approaches.
Below is an attempt to explain this sequence of events,
updated as new developments are reported.
Sequence
of events:
On June 28, 2009,
the elected President of Honduras, Manuel Zelaya, was
taken to the airport (allegedly in his pajamas) and put on a plane for
Costa Rica. Under the constitution, the next in line was the head of
Congress, Roberto Micheletti, who took power, with the support of the
military in what many term a military coup. The impetus for the ouster
was a "non-binding consultation" Zelaya planned to hold on his proposal
to set up a comission to revise the Honduran constitution. If the
comission met with popular support, it would probably have been voted
on in the November presidential election. The Honduran Supreme Court
ruled the "consultation" unconstitutional and blocked the distribution
of ballots; Zelaya ordered the ballots to be distributed anyway, and
that night found himself escorted by members of the military to the
airport. (See the BBC for a fuller background
story; the citizen news source Groundreport
offers video and images of events on June 28).
Since then the interim government, headed by Interim President Roberto
Micheletti has been running the country, imposing road blocks
and curfews, and even closing the airports for a time and shutting
down media outlets "sympathetic" to Zelaya. Most Western nations along
with the Organization of Americna States (OAS) called
on Micheletti to step down and reinstate Zeleya. Micheletti, backed by
the miltary, refused. The OAS suspended Honduras' membership in the
organization and the World Bank suspended much-needed aid. European
Union member nations withdrew diplomats from Honduras, as did Bolivia,
Ecuador and Venezuela. There have been protests,
escalating when Zelaya returned to Honduras and took up residence in
the Brasilian embassy in Tegucigalpa on September 21. Various
presidents of other
nations, most notably Costa Rican president Oscar Arias, and
organizations have tried to broker some kind of power-sharing
agreement, so far to no avail. Zelaya appealed to the
United Nations for help, saying that it is Micheletti who has
created a "dictatorship," and that he
only wants peace. The Organization of American States
(OAS) was reported
to be close to a deal in early October. On October 29 a peace accord
brokered by the US was signed under which the two leaders were to set
up a national unity government by November 5 to administer the
election. That did not happen, and on November 6 the US State
Department issued the Travel Alert above.
On November 19,
President Micheletti said
in an address to the nation that he would to take a "leave of absence"
from the Presidency from November 25-December 2, the period of the
election--reserving the right to return to power in the event of
increased violence. Zelaya has dismissed the decision and called
on his supporters to boycott the elections if they cannot be delayed
until after the decision about his return to power for the remainder of
his term. Several governments have said they will not accept the
outcome of the election (most notably Argentina and Brazil). The US and
Panama have said that they will recognize the outcome of the election.
Still to be decided: who will run the country until the new President
takes office on January 27, 2010. The October 29 deal requires the
Honduras Congress to decide, but that vote will not be held before
December 2-- after the election.
Why the big deal?
It depends who
you ask. Was Zelaya (elected as a member of the Liberal
party in 2005), as he says, looking to improve the conditions of the
people by finding ways to increase their representation and raise the
minimum wage, or was this a bold-faced effort to change term-limits and
allow Zelaya to be re-elected as his oponents claim? Micheletti claimed
in an interview
that Zelaya wants to "establish a dictatorship" (BBC). Zelaya, although
a businessman and rancher himself, was certainly closer to left-wing
politicians in the region than many business people liked and as his
term of office progressed, he took an increasingly anti-American stance
even though the US is Honduras' major trading partner. He is reported to
have been praised by Cuban president Fidel Castro. He was supported by
Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez, who himself used constitutional
reform to
accomplish many of the social programs Zelaya claimed to favor. And to
increase term limits to allow him to accomplish those changes.
Constitutions are a sensitive matter in every country, and more so in
countries like Honduas that have a relatively short history of
democracy. Under the constitution that caused these problems, elections
are
required to be held in November, and are scheduled for November 29. How
democratic they might be remains
to be seen. The current constitution limits the president to one, four
year term. We wait to see what will happen in November.
Who is running in the November 29
elections?
Well, for a start, neither Zelaya or
Micheletti, who are actually from the same political party. That party,
the Liberal Party, is running
a candidate though: Elvin Santos, a business leader and
Zelaya’s former vice-president.
The major National Party candidate
is Porforio Lobo, who lost to Zelaya in 2005 by less than 70,000 votes.
In October the the Tegucigalpa-based newspaper La Prensa
reported that according to a
CID-Gallup Poll of 1,420 adults
Lobo was leading Santos by 16 points.
Who is the real loser?
Well, it could be the fragile democracy of Honduras.
Or the poor who could have been helped by Chavez-like reform. But most
agree that the main contender for the title is the Honduran economy,
which Honduras This Week says has been "set back ten years" by this
series of events. Reuters
also reports that the freeze on aid from foreign nations is harming
health and welfare programs.
You can learn nore about Latin American politics in a Latin American
Studies class, and by reading the media coverage of events like this
online.
To read about the impact this is having on the children and
organizations we work with, check out the newsletter by
the Reverend Richard Kuntz, the Director of El Hogar Projects, based in
Tegucigalpa (the nation's capital).
Children and Children's
Organizations:
Much has changed since the DHP started going to Honduras
two decades ago. When we first went the poverty was in your face all
the time. The description below from Casa Alianza (Covenant
House) was accurate--indeed on an early trip one Drew student
challenegd a glue seller about his purposes and begged him to stop (to
no avail, although the crowd that gathered clearly agreed with her).
"In the square in San Pedro Sula, right across from the
McDonalds, is a man who sells nothing but glue. He sets up a card table
and fills it with the little tubes of solvent-based glue. That glue is
for street children to buy and inhale. It is made in and exported from
the United States or made by US companies in Central America. Unlike
glues of a similar kind (and brand) sold in the US, this glue does not
contain nausea-inducing mustard seed. Men like this one can be seen
selling glue to Honduran street children in every major Honduran city."
Street children purchased the glue because inhaling it
reduced their hunger and numbed them to the emotional and physical pain
they endured every day--both physical and sexual abuse in addition to
the sense of hopelessness and abandonment.
In the early 1990s, the square described above contained
an open market and the street children gathered there to beg for money
and food scraps that the vendors dropped or donated at the end of the
day. In the later 1990s we started reading press reports of police
murders of street children in major cities, but especially San Pedro
Sula. The market was banished to closer to the train tracks and the
children vanished. Taxi drivers told us that if they were not killed or
imprisoned they were simply driven out of the city and dropped off;
left to fend for themselves miles from home and shelter. Large American
chain stores filled the mall off the square, and now there is a
fountain and flowers and on summer evenings old and young gather to
dance to local bands.
On the face of it the problem no longer exists. But the
fact that street children and general signs of poverty are not in your
face does not mean they no longer exist. You just have to look. Go to
the parts of the city were tourists do not go; check under the
underpasses; visit the city dump; or go to rural areas and you will see
them. And what you see will still break your heart.
After Hurricane Mitch the DHP volunteered in a number of
village rebuilding projects. New houses replaced the temporary shacks
built by the Hodurans displaced by the hurricane. The children helped
us carry rocks and cider blocks up precariously steep and muddy
hills--you can see pictures--of them doing
so. We knew that their distended bellies were not a sign of good healt,
but we wondered why so many of them had noticably lighter skin and hair
than their parents. Being polite North Americans we didn't ask. Then a
student learned about Kwashiorkor in a class at Drew. There are a
number of nutitional deficiencies that cause changes in hair and skin
pigmentation; coupled with the other symptoms we observed, it is clear
these children were starving in front of our very eyes. The World
Health Organization lists hunger as the most important world health
issue and malnutrition as contributing to 50% of all child mortality.
Malnutrition, in the form of iodine deficiency is also the the most
common cause of mental impairment, reducing the world's IQ by an
estimated billion points!
The point here? You don't have to see the children
begging to understand that there is work to be done. And you don't
always see when a problem is right in front of you. A second point:
what you learn in classes that seem unrelated to volunteer trips like
this one can help you understand what you see and experience, making
you a more effective citizen of the world, able to assess problems and
bring researched knowledge to bear on the process of finding a
solution.
In the last half-decade, DHP has mostly worked in
childrens homes that rescue children from a life of poverty. Some work
with families who apply for children to be given a space in a home.
Others include children who are placed there by the government or
referree dfrom other organizations or churches when they are orphaned.
We can't save everyone, but every life that can be improved is a step
in the right direction.
back to top
The 2009 Eathquakes:
On May 28 at 2.25am local time an earthquake of 7.3
magnitude occurred off the northern coast of Honduras, about 80 miles
from La Ceiba, where Drew students were staying as they volunteered at
Helping Honduras Kids (HHK) in nearby Agua Caliente. A second quake
measuring 4.8 followed 42 minutes later slightly west of the first, and
additional quakes of 4.5 and 4.6 occurred on the same faultline at
8.45pm local time and 6.51 am local time on May 29th (see the U.S.
Government Geological Survey website for information about the quakes,
and maps, and USGS NEIC for a list of all recent quakes). The quakes
occurred about 6 miles below the ocean floor, and a tsunami watch was
announced after the first quake, but quickly cancelled. There were some
power outages and email was down in many areas, but cell phone signals
worked and the group reported no significant damage in La Ceiba or the
surrpunding areas. Seven deaths were reported overall, mostly as
a result of falling trees and everal bridges were damaged but it was
determined that the students were not at risk and the trip continued.
(See the L.A. Times for news coverage--there is basically one story
that is being recycled in many media.)
Honduras is bordered on the north and south by fault
lines, and small earthquakes are not usual as the plates move and
settle. Prior to 2009, the last big earthquake on Honduras occurred in
1999 close to the site of the 2009 quake. That one measured 6.7 and
occurred at about the same depth below the ocean floor. Both
quakes--and many of the other earthquakes in Honduras, were on the Swan
Island fault, which is the very steep southern boundary of the more
than 5000 meter deep Cayman Trough. Read more--and track
eathquakes--at the US
Geological Survey website. Learn more in a Geology class!
back to top
Further reading:
Honduras, general
Eric Llamovitch. Honduras
(Ulysses Travel Guides) There are several other tourist-type guides of
Honduras. This one contains maps of Tegucigalpa and San Pedro Sula,
useful addresses, and lots of general information about the country.
And pictures of course!
Peter Dale Scott and
Jonathan Marshall. Cocaine Politics:
Drugs, Armies, and the CIA in Central America
(Berkeley: Univ. of California, 1991). Chapter Three provides a larger
history of the relationship between the US and Honduras from the
"Banana Republic" days to the present. The rest of the book puts this
into the larger Central American context.
Andrew Ross, ed. No Sweat: Fashion, Free
Trade, and the Rights of Garment Workers
(New York: Verso, 1997). From Kathie Lee to Disney, everyone is making
use of Honduras' Free Trade Zones to produce goods for the US market.
This book tells you more than you wanted to know about that, and more
important, offers some suggestions about what you can do to help.
back to top
Volunteering
Robert Coles. The
Call of Service: A Witness to Idealism
(Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1993). A discussion of the various forms of
volunteerism Coles has studied, and a celebration of "service" in all
its forms. Coles describes what he learned from volunteering everywhere
from SNCC to soup kitchens, and speaks bluntly about the reactions of
those who are being "helped" and the possible pitfalls for
volunteers--in addition to the benefits for everyone.
Michael Maren. The Road to Hell: The Ravaging Effects
of Foreign Aid and International Charity
(New York: Simon and Shuster, 1997) A more chilling look at the
business of charity from a former volunteer who served over nineteen
years in various African nations working for several different aid
organizations. Maren touches on some of the same dangers as Coles, but
on a much larger scale. This book isn't about Honduras, but it should
make you think about the long term implications of every kind of
charitable aid you offer.
Janet Poppendieck. Sweat Charity: Emergency Food Aid and
the End of Entitlement.
(NY: Penguin, 1998) Another chilling look at charity; this time in the
United States. Poppendieck describes the volunteer "industry" that has
grown up around food banks and food pantries, and explores the local
and national implications of our commitment to providing charitable
food aid. Like The Road to Hell, this book is not about Honduras, but
it has direct relevance to the kinds of aid programs we establish and
support at home and abroad, and to the relationship between behavior
and attitude.
back to top
|